Headlines »

June 23, 2024 – 12:05 am | Comments Off on G-d Is Knocking, Answer the Call17 views

Moses appointed twelve emissaries to scout out the Holy Land and return with a report. The representative for the tribe of Ephraim was Moses’ primary disciple, Joshua. Until this time, the lad’s name was Oshua. But Moses added a letter to his name and called him Joshua.
Rashi, the famed eleventh …

Read the full story »
Parsha Insights

Where Biblical law and Torah tale is brought vividly to life


The Jewish perspective on topical and controversial subjects

Life Cycle

Probing for meaning in our journey and its milestones.

Yearly Cycle

Discover depth and mystique in the annual Jewish festivals

Rabbi’s Desk

Seeking life’s lessons in news items and current events

Home » B'Chukotai

The Minyan Effect

Submitted by on May 20, 2022 – 8:00 pmNo Comment | 1,052 views

Minyan is a quorum of ten and it is a Jewish tradition to pray with a quorum. In fact, the holiest parts of prayer, the sanctification of G-d’s name and the chanting from the Torah, may only occur in the presence of a minyan. We believe that our prayers have extra potency in the presence of a minyan.

It matters not whether the assembled are righteous or wicked. They need only be willing to pray. We derive the quorum of ten from a shameful episode of Jewish history. You might recall that when our ancestors were in the desert preparing to enter the Holy Land, they sent spies to scout the land. The spies returned with a terrible report about Israel and the people wept.

G-d was upset with them for trusting the specious and blatantly false report over His own assurances that Israel was a wonderful land. When G-d complained to Moses, He described these ten spies as a wicked congregation. Shockingly, our sages derived from these words that the minimum quorum for a prayer congregation is ten.[1] This tells us that even if the people are as wicked as the spies, it is still a minyan. So long as there are ten Jews that have gathered to pray.

Our sages put it like this, when there is a minyan, G-d is present in the room. They also said that G-d never turns down the prayers of a minyan.[2]

Rabbi Chiya
The Talmud relates a fascinating story about Rabbi Chiya and his two sons, Yehuda and Chizkiya. The story begins with Elijah the prophet who frequently attended the academy of Rabbi Yehudah the prince. One day, Elijah was late to the lecture. He explained that he had to awaken Abraham and accompany him to his prayers, then Isaac, and finally Jacob.

Rabbi Yehudah asked why they didn’t pray in unison? Elijah explained that if those three would ever pray together, G-d would not be able to turn them down and the Mashiach would immediately arrive. Hearing this, Rabbi Yehudah asked whether anyone on earth enjoyed similar privileges? Elijah replied in the affirmative. Rabbi Chiya and his sons.

The next time there was a drought, Rabbi Yehudah appointed Rabbi Chiya and his sons to lead the prayers. As soon as they uttered the words, “He causes rain to fall,” the sky clouded over, and the rains fell. They were about to say, “He who revives the dead,” and the world trembled. In Heaven they asked, “Who revealed the secret [of Rabbi Chiya’s powers] to the world?” Elijah was brought before G-d and given sixty fiery lashes. Wanting to prevent Rabbi Chiya and his sons from praying for Mashiach, Elijah appeared among the congregation in the guise of a fiery bear, and they dispersed.[3]

This is a fascinating story, but it begs a simple question. Did Rabbi Chiya never pray with his sons before? What made this event so different?

The answer is that Rabbi Chiya prayed with his sons many times, but they had never been appointed to lead a minyan. This underscores the power of prayer with a minyan. Even the great Rabbi Chiya and his sons could only realize their supreme privilege when praying in the presence of a minyan.

The question is, how does this work and why?

G-d Arrives First
Maimonides offers a curious distinction between G-d’s presence in a minyan and His presence on other occasions such as when Jews study Torah. Maimonides said that on those occasions, first the people gather and then G-d makes His appearance. When a minyan gathers to pray, G-d precedes them and welcomes them.

This sounds like a wonderful honor to the assembled; G-d Himself rushes to greet them. But there must be more to it. Why does G-d rush to greet a minyan more so than groups that perform other mitzvot?

G-d’s Prayer
The Kabbalists explained it on the basis of another fascinating Talmudic tale. Rabbi Yishmael the high priest once entered the Holy of Holies and G-d asked him for a blessing. Rabbi Yishmael replied among other things, “May it be Your will that Your mercy overrides your anger and your other attributes, and that You treat Your children with compassion.” To this, G-d agreed.

The Kabbalists inferred from this that G-d prays every day for His mercy to override His anger. However, when we approach G-d in prayer, He doesn’t always respond with mercy because in addition to being our father, He is also our king. As our sovereign, He is sometimes compelled to bring His wrath and judgement to bear. This is surely painful for a king who is also a father.

Yet, when a minyan gathers, the power of unified prayer is so intense that it transcends the individual and even the collective prayers of the people. Rather than the people beseeching G-d for mercy, the people become the conduit of G-d’s own prayers. Rather than the people begging G-d for healing and sustenance, G-d hears His own wishes to grant them healing and sustenance. The prayer of the people merely echoes G-d’s prayer. G-d speaks first, and His words are heard in the prayers of the people.

The energy generated by the merged prayer of ten sacred interlocking souls, praying with love for each other and blended in absolute unity, arouses G-d’s love for His children. He thus prefaces their prayers with His. Before they even make their requests, He is already desirous of granting it. Thus, their prayers become channels for G-d’s prayer that His mercy override His anger and other attributes.

This is, perhaps, the inner meaning of Maimonides’ claim that G-d precedes the minyan gathering. On the surface it means that G-d arrives first. Beneath the surface it means that G-d speaks first, and the words of the assembled are mere echoes of G-d’s words. This explains why the prayer of the minyan is never turned away. It is not someone else praying before G-d. It is an articulation of G-d’s intrinsic wishes.[4]

Ten Women One Oven
This week, the Torah portion includes a difficult tract. It is the punishment that awaits our people should we ever, G-d forbid, turn from G-d’s commandments. Our sages often taught that what appears to be a curse, is in fact a hidden blessing. A blessing so intense that it can’t present directly, as is, because it would overwhelm us. It is thus disguised as a curse.[5]

One of the curses that we read this week is that ten women will bake their bread in one oven. What we learned today reveals the hidden blessing of this passage. The bond between G-d and the Jews is like that between a man and a woman. Ten women represent a minyan. The bread represents the substance of our relationship. The Torah we study, our reciprocal love, and G-d’s blessings. They are well baked because they are heated by a single collective flame—baked the single oven of a minyan. And this brings blessing.

[1] Berachos 21b. It is derived by linking this verse to Leviticus 22:32, I will be sanctified among the children of Israel.

[2] Talmud, Sanhedrin 39a and berachos 8a.

[3] Talmud, Baba Metzia 85b.

[4] Sefer Hamaamarim 5626, pp. 284-285.

[5] Talmud, Moed Katan 9b.

Tags: ,